International Society of Surgery (ISS)

Société Internationale de Chirurgie (SIC)

Integrated Societies: IATSIC | IASMEN | BSI | ISDS

EXTERNAL VALIDATION OF THE MSKCC NOMOGRAM FOR PREDICTING SENTINEL NODE STATUS IN EARLY BREAST CANCER: A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW AND META-ANALYSIS justin.james@monash.edu

3103-07
EXTERNAL VALIDATION OF THE MSKCC NOMOGRAM FOR PREDICTING SENTINEL NODE STATUS IN EARLY BREAST CANCER: A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW AND META-ANALYSIS
Author Details
8
Including the presenting author
Justin James justin.james@monash.edu Eastern Health, Melbourne Melbourne Australia *
Mohammadali Ahmadipur m.a.ahmadip1@gmail.com Deakin University Melbourne Australia
Tegan Ormston tegan.ormston@gmail.com Eastern Health, Melbourne Melbourne Australia
Emily Schembri emily.schembri@monash.edu Eastern Health, Melbourne Melbourne Australia
Kirti Mehta drkirtimehta@gmail.com Eastern Health, Melbourne Melbourne Australia
Shomik Sengupta shomik.sengupta@monash.edu Eastern Health, Melbourne Melbourne Australia
Christobel Saunders christobel.saunders@unimelb.edu.au University of Melbourne Melbourne Australia
Michael Law mlaw.besurg@gmail.com Australia
Justin James
justin.james@monash.edu
Australia
Abstract
Oral or Poster
Axillary management in early breast cancer (EBC) is shifting toward de-escalation, with sentinel node biopsy (SNB) increasingly questioned in low-risk patients. The Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Centre (MSKCC) nomogram is the most widely used mathematical model for predicting sentinel node status. This systematic review and meta-analysis aimed to evaluate its external validation, methodological quality, and predictive performance.
A comprehensive search of MEDLINE, Embase, and Cochrane Central was conducted through July 2025 to identify external validation studies of the MSKCC nomogram in clinically node-negative EBC patients. Eligible studies reported discrimination metrics such as the area under the ROC curve (AUC). Risk of bias was assessed using PROBAST. Where confidence intervals (CIs) were not provided, they were estimated using the Hanley & McNeil method. A random-effects meta-analysis was performed.
Eight studies were identified, of which seven provided sufficient data for pooled analysis. Six were rated as low risk of bias, and two as moderate risk. The pooled AUC across included studies was 0.73 (95% CI: 0.476–0.984), supporting moderate discriminatory ability. No studies were judged to have high overall risk of bias.
The MSKCC nomogram demonstrates consistent, though moderate, discriminatory performance across external cohorts. In the current era of axillary de-escalation, nomogram-based strategies may support selective omission of SNB in EBC patients, offering a potential pathway toward safe, individualized axillary management.
 
Only accept images in .jpg or .png format. The image size must not exceed 1 MB.
 
Only accept images in .jpg or .png format. The image size must not exceed 1 MB.
Category
5 Breast Surgery organized by BSI
5.02 Breast Cancer
Submitted
218
Abstract Prizes
Yes
- Presenting author must register to the congress by 30 November 2025
- Author must submit a full-length manuscript conforming to the format of orignial articles in the World Journal of Surgery WJS by 30 November 2025
No
- Author must be age 40 or younger
- One of the authors must be a member of ISDS
- Presenting author must register to the congress by 30 November 2025
- Author must submit a full-length manuscript to the World Journal of Surgery WJS by 30 November 2025
No
- Author must be age 40 or younger
- One of the authors must be a member of ISDS
- Presenting author must register to the congress by 30 November 2025
- Author must submit a full-length manuscript to the World Journal of Surgery WJS by 30 November 2025